Software Hosted in Germany Hosted in Germany
Secure. Fast. Reliable.  
Digital data transmission - in accordance with sect. 87c of the German Fiscal Code
Digital data transmission

 

The entire world of tax knowledge

Lohnsteuer kompakt FAQs

 


(2021) Minimum standard of living: Are the child allowances unconstitutionally low?

Dieser Text bezieht sich auf die Steuererklärung 2021. Die aktuelle Version für die Steuererklärung 2025 finden Sie unter:
(2025): Minimum standard of living: Are the child allowances unconstitutionally low?

The minimum subsistence level for children must be exempt from tax for constitutional reasons. This is achieved through the child allowance and the BEA allowance (for care, education and training needs). The tax office automatically checks as part of the annual tax assessment whether these two allowances or the child benefit paid during the year are more favourable for the parents.

While the BEA allowance has remained unchanged at 2,640 Euro since 2010, the child allowance was increased annually from 2015 to 2018 after four years of stagnation. It amounts to 4,368 Euro (2010-2014), 4,512 Euro (2015), 4,608 Euro (2016), 4,716 Euro (2017), 4,788 Euro (2018), 4,980 Euro (2019).

In February 2016, the Lower Saxony Finance Court expressed serious doubts about the constitutionality of the child allowance for 2014. It should be at least 4,440 Euro instead of 4,368 Euro. Therefore, parents were entitled to a suspension or cancellation of enforcement (Lower Saxony FG of 16.02.2016, 7 V 237/15).

The Federal Fiscal Court also agreed that an application for suspension of enforcement was justified for 2014, insofar as it related to an amount of 72 Euro by which the child allowance was too low (BFH decision of 21.07.2016, V B 37/16).

Currently, the Lower Saxony Finance Court has taken further action: The child allowance was not only unconstitutionally low in 2014, but the entire calculation method for the child allowance is unconstitutional - and therefore the allowance was also too low in other years. The court has therefore suspended a legal action and referred the question to the Federal Constitutional Court as to whether the statutory regulation on the amount of child allowances is unconstitutional (FG Niedersachsen of 02.12.2016, 7 K 83/16).

  • When determining taxable income, an amount equivalent to the minimum subsistence level must remain tax-free. No income tax may be levied on the part of the income that would be received as a social benefit in the event of need. The amount of the minimum subsistence level is determined by the Federal Government every two years.
  • The child allowance set by the legislator based on an average calculation assumes a material minimum subsistence level for all children that is lower than the social welfare requirement for a child aged 6 and over. This also applies to older or adult children who are considered due to, for example, training or disability.
  • The finance judges criticise that the child allowance is designed independently of age, while the social welfare requirements for children are age-dependent and increase with the child's age. When determining the child allowance, only an average minimum subsistence level of 258 Euro per month is assumed, which is below the social benefit entitlement of a six-year-old child (standard rate 2014: 261 Euro per month).
  • The finance judges fundamentally criticise the calculation of the child allowance because the same minimum subsistence level applies for an adult child as for a minor child, but not as for an adult. This is neither appropriate nor consistent and is therefore no longer covered by the legislator's discretion. Therefore, the child allowance for the younger daughter must be 444 Euro higher and for the older daughter 1,346 Euro higher.
Lohnsteuer kompakt

The Federal Constitutional Court must now decide - but this can easily take five to six years. The decision is significant for all parents who are entitled to child benefit or a child allowance for their children. An increase in child allowances not only affects those taxpayers for whom the child allowance is more favourable than child benefit, but affects everyone, as child allowances are always taken into account when determining church tax and the solidarity surcharge.

Text reviews: Minimum standard of living: Are the child allowances unconstitutionally low?

         

5.00 of 5
Number of reviews: 1

Finanztip

"Die Programme überzeugten mit einem großen Leistungsumfang, einer exakten Berechnung und allen Zusatzfunktionen. Auch Ehepaare sind hier gut aufgehoben."

Finanztip 04/2026

WirtschaftsWoche

"Der Pionier für Online-Steuererklärungen bietet Nutzern nun zusätzlich einen Import ihres digitalen Steuerbescheids und prüft auch die dort enthaltenen Daten automatisch auf Optimierungspotenzial."

WirtschaftsWoche 16/2026

Chip

"Neben einer KI-gestützten Steuerhilfe sind die Bescheidprüfung und eine effizientere digitale Kommunikation mit dem Finanzamt hinzugekommen. [...] Neben Lohnsteuerbescheinigungen kann der Cloud-Dienst nun auch Rechnungen erkennen und verarbeiten."

Chip 03/2026